The FCA’s Consumer Duty – Measuring Cultural Change
The FCA has long emphasised the importance of a robust organisational culture in achieving positive consumer outcomes. The introduction of the Consumer Duty underscores this focus, urging firms to examine their operations and ensure that their culture supports the principles of good customer service and ethical business conduct. This article delves into the FCA’s stance on cultural change and offers practical advice on how firms can measure and demonstrate this change effectively.

Understanding the FCA’s Position on Cultural Change

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has identified four key drivers of culture within firms: purpose, leadership, approach to rewarding and managing people, and governance. These elements collectively shape the environment in which decisions are made and actions are taken, impacting both employees and customers. The FCA’s 2020 paper on transforming culture highlights the necessity of embedding a clear and meaningful purpose at the core of a firm’s business model, aligning it with positive outcomes for all stakeholders.

The Consumer Duty and Cultural Change

The Consumer Duty, a central element of the FCA’s regulatory strategy, mandates that firms place the interests of their customers at the heart of their operations. According to FG22/5, “Firms should ensure that the interests of their customers are central to their culture and purpose and embedded throughout the organisation.” This directive requires firms to integrate customer-centric considerations into their business strategies from inception to execution.

Cultural Change -Example of Misalignment

Consider a scenario where a firm identifies a market gap and develops a new product solely based on potential sales. If this product fails to meet customer needs or causes harm, the firm would not be compliant with the Consumer Duty. Instead, the firm should assess the product’s potential impact on customers, ensuring it is beneficial and aligned with the principles of the duty.

The Role of the Board Report

The Board Report is pivotal in defining and assessing a firm’s culture. It should begin with a statement from the Consumer Duty Champion, outlining customer outcomes and the degree to which the duty has been embedded within the firm. The report should then evaluate whether the duty has been properly understood and disseminated throughout the organisation.

Key Components of the Board Report

1. Leadership Assessment
– Are leaders setting clear expectations regarding behaviours?
– Do leaders’ actions reflect the behaviours they expect from others?
– Are decisions made with the intended culture in mind, prioritising customer well-being over profit?

2. Reward and Management Approach
– Are bonus payments and commissions balanced with quality measures?
– Do quality measures focus on supporting customers and ensuring product suitability?
– Are staff adequately trained to meet the needs of the target market and identify vulnerable customers?
– Do quality measures promote good customer outcomes?

3. Governance
– Are processes designed to identify and mitigate customer harm?
– Is there an equal focus on measuring customer outcomes as there is on measuring profit?
– Are senior managers informed about the impact of the organisation on customers?
– Is the Consumer Duty Champion actively promoting a customer-centric culture?

4. Purpose
– Does the firm’s core purpose align with customer needs?
– How does the firm’s purpose influence staff behaviour and decision-making?

Measuring Cultural Change

The ability to measure cultural change is crucial for demonstrating compliance with the Consumer Duty. The following indicators can help firms assess whether their culture is aligned with regulatory expectations:

Leadership
– Clarity of messages from leaders regarding expected behaviours.
– Consistency between leaders’ actions and their stated expectations.
– Decisions made with customer well-being as a priority.

Reward and Management
– Balance of financial incentives with quality measures.
– Training and support provided to staff for understanding product suitability and customer needs.
– Measures in place to identify and support vulnerable customers.

Governance
– Processes to identify and address customer harm.
– Balanced focus on profit and customer outcomes.
– Senior management’s attention to customer impact.
– Active involvement of the Consumer Duty Champion in promoting a customer-centric culture.

Purpose
– Alignment of the firm’s purpose with customer needs.
– Influence of the firm’s purpose on staff behaviour and decision-making.

Practical Steps for Firms

1. Conduct Regular Reviews
– Regularly review and update business strategies to ensure alignment with the Consumer Duty.
– Use board reports to track progress and identify areas for improvement.

2. Engage Leadership
– Ensure leaders are committed to fostering a culture that prioritises customer well-being.
– Provide training for leaders to understand their role in driving cultural change.

3. Focus on Training and Development
– Invest in comprehensive training programmes for staff at all levels.
– Emphasise the importance of understanding customer needs and providing appropriate support.

4. Implement Robust Governance Structures
– Develop governance frameworks that prioritise customer outcomes alongside financial performance.
– Regularly review processes to ensure they are effective in preventing customer harm.

5. Foster a Clear Purpose
– Define and communicate a clear, customer-centric purpose.
– Ensure this purpose is embedded in every aspect of the organisation’s operations.

Cultural Change – Conclusion

By embedding the principles of the Consumer Duty into their culture, firms can not only meet regulatory expectations but also drive meaningful improvements in customer outcomes. Regular assessments, strong leadership, effective governance, and a clear organisational purpose are key components of this cultural transformation. Firms that succeed in these areas will be well-placed to thrive in a regulatory environment that increasingly prioritises consumer well-being.

By following these guidelines and continuously striving to improve, firms can ensure they not only comply with the FCA’s Consumer Duty but also foster a culture that prioritises and protects customer interests.

Click on the banner to book your FCA Compliance Specialist Discovery Call, Today!